U.K. unemployment will rise in 2011 in what will be a “worse” year for hiring as the government cuts public jobs as part of plans to reduce the budget deficit, the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development said.
Payrolls will drop by 200,000 next year, with public-sector employment falling by 120,000 and private-sector jobs by 80,000, the London-based group said in a report today. Unemployment may rise to 9 percent, it said. Consumers’ spending power will also be eroded, with the CIPD forecasting below-inflation pay increases of 2 percent in 2011.
Prime Minister David Cameron’s plans to lower the budget gap will cost the economy about 330,000 government jobs by 2015, according to the Office for Budget Responsibility. Still, the watchdog has said the loss will be more than offset by the creation of about 1.5 million private-sector jobs.
“It will be a ‘fingers crossed’ year for the economy,” CIPD Chief Economic Adviser John Philpott said in the report. “This doesn’t mean that we are facing a return to the dire recession days of late 2008 and 2009, but nonetheless 2011 will probably feel like another year in the economic doldrums, rather than the start of a return to prosperity.”
While jobless claims fell for a second month in November, according to a Dec. 15 report, the decline was less economists forecast in a Bloomberg News survey. In the quarter through October, unemployment measured by International Labour Organization methods rose by 35,000 to 2.5 million people and the jobless rate increased to 7.9 percent.
Also in November, inflation unexpectedly accelerated to 3.3 percent, the fastest in six months. The Bank of England forecasts that annual consumer-price growth will remain above its 2 percent target through 2011.
“Most workers will feel a squeeze in their real living standards, with pay rises still relatively modest against a backdrop of higher prices,” Philpott said. It will be a “jobs light-pay tight” year.”
To contact the reporter on this story: Fergal O’Brien in London at fobrien@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: John Fraher at jfraher@bloomberg.net
2010년 12월 29일 수요일
South Korea's Factory Output, Current-Account Surplus Signal Higher Rates
South Korea’s industrial production increased for the 17th straight month and the current account may post a $29 billion surplus this year, supporting the case for the central bank to increase borrowing costs again.
Factory output rose 10.4 percent in November from a year earlier, Statistics Korea said in Gwacheon today. The current- account surplus is expected to widen “a lot” in December after narrowing to a seven-month low of $1.93 billion last month on rising imports, the Bank of Korea said separately.
The data signal exports are weathering a 35 percent appreciation in the nation’s currency against the dollar since March last year, the biggest in Asia. Moves to pare the gain by reviving taxes on overseas investment in government debt and discouraging foreign-currency speculation contributed to the won’s steepest decline in six months in November.
“The won’s recent weakness due to capital controls is apparently helping exports hold up,” said Kong Dong Rak, a fixed-income analyst at Taurus Investment & Securities Co. in Seoul. “Given solid economic growth and growing inflation pressures, the central bank will likely discuss a rate increase next month and act in February.”
The won rose 0.6 percent to 1,139.75 as of 12:03 p.m. in Seoul, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The currency fell 2.9 percent in November, the steepest drop since May. The benchmark Kospi stock index was little changed.
‘Robust’ Exports
The current-account surplus “is expected to widen a lot next month as exports remain robust,” Lee Young Bog, an official at the Bank of Korea, said in Seoul today. “This year’s total surplus won’t be much different from the $29 billion forecast earlier this month.”
The central bank left the nation’s benchmark interest rate at 2.5 percent on Dec. 9 after raising borrowing costs by 0.25 percentage point in each of July and November from a record-low 2 percent. The benchmark lags behind last month’s 3.3 percent pace of inflation.
Officials from Brazil to Taiwan and Thailand are trying to curb currency gains driven by capital inflows. They have faulted the U.S. Federal Reserve’s plan to inject $600 billion into the world’s biggest economy for threatening to depress the dollar and intensifying capital flight to their higher-yielding markets.
South Korea said earlier this month that it aims to apply a levy on banks’ foreign-exchange borrowings, will strengthen punishment for inappropriate reporting of currency trades and may tighten rules on derivatives in a bid to control incoming foreign funds and prevent sudden capital flight.
Imports Climb
November’s current-account surplus compared with a revised $4.89 billion in October, the Bank of Korea said in a statement in Seoul today. The current account is the broadest measure of international trade, tracking goods, services and investment income.
Total exports on a customs-cleared basis, which excludes ships, rose 23.6 percent last month from a year earlier, while imports climbed 32.7 percent, according to the statement.
The increase in industrial production followed a 13.5 percent rise in October, Statistics Korea said. Output advanced 1.4 percent in November from October.
Exports account for about half of South Korea’s economy and have boosted earnings this year at companies including Samsung Electronics Co., Asia’s biggest maker of semiconductors, flat screens and mobile phones.
Gross domestic product increased 4.4 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier. It is set to rise 4.5 percent in 2011, while consumer prices may increase 3.5 percent next year, from 2.9 percent in 2010, according to the central bank.
To contact the reporters on this story: Eunkyung Seo in Seoul at eseo3@bloomberg.net; William Sim in Seoul at wsim2@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Chris Anstey at canstey@bloomberg.net
Factory output rose 10.4 percent in November from a year earlier, Statistics Korea said in Gwacheon today. The current- account surplus is expected to widen “a lot” in December after narrowing to a seven-month low of $1.93 billion last month on rising imports, the Bank of Korea said separately.
The data signal exports are weathering a 35 percent appreciation in the nation’s currency against the dollar since March last year, the biggest in Asia. Moves to pare the gain by reviving taxes on overseas investment in government debt and discouraging foreign-currency speculation contributed to the won’s steepest decline in six months in November.
“The won’s recent weakness due to capital controls is apparently helping exports hold up,” said Kong Dong Rak, a fixed-income analyst at Taurus Investment & Securities Co. in Seoul. “Given solid economic growth and growing inflation pressures, the central bank will likely discuss a rate increase next month and act in February.”
The won rose 0.6 percent to 1,139.75 as of 12:03 p.m. in Seoul, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The currency fell 2.9 percent in November, the steepest drop since May. The benchmark Kospi stock index was little changed.
‘Robust’ Exports
The current-account surplus “is expected to widen a lot next month as exports remain robust,” Lee Young Bog, an official at the Bank of Korea, said in Seoul today. “This year’s total surplus won’t be much different from the $29 billion forecast earlier this month.”
The central bank left the nation’s benchmark interest rate at 2.5 percent on Dec. 9 after raising borrowing costs by 0.25 percentage point in each of July and November from a record-low 2 percent. The benchmark lags behind last month’s 3.3 percent pace of inflation.
Officials from Brazil to Taiwan and Thailand are trying to curb currency gains driven by capital inflows. They have faulted the U.S. Federal Reserve’s plan to inject $600 billion into the world’s biggest economy for threatening to depress the dollar and intensifying capital flight to their higher-yielding markets.
South Korea said earlier this month that it aims to apply a levy on banks’ foreign-exchange borrowings, will strengthen punishment for inappropriate reporting of currency trades and may tighten rules on derivatives in a bid to control incoming foreign funds and prevent sudden capital flight.
Imports Climb
November’s current-account surplus compared with a revised $4.89 billion in October, the Bank of Korea said in a statement in Seoul today. The current account is the broadest measure of international trade, tracking goods, services and investment income.
Total exports on a customs-cleared basis, which excludes ships, rose 23.6 percent last month from a year earlier, while imports climbed 32.7 percent, according to the statement.
The increase in industrial production followed a 13.5 percent rise in October, Statistics Korea said. Output advanced 1.4 percent in November from October.
Exports account for about half of South Korea’s economy and have boosted earnings this year at companies including Samsung Electronics Co., Asia’s biggest maker of semiconductors, flat screens and mobile phones.
Gross domestic product increased 4.4 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier. It is set to rise 4.5 percent in 2011, while consumer prices may increase 3.5 percent next year, from 2.9 percent in 2010, according to the central bank.
To contact the reporters on this story: Eunkyung Seo in Seoul at eseo3@bloomberg.net; William Sim in Seoul at wsim2@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Chris Anstey at canstey@bloomberg.net
South Korea Limits Banks' Access to Currency Derivatives After Won Gains
South Korea plans to tighten curbs on banks’ holdings of foreign-exchange derivatives, lowering existing limits by a fifth, according to an official at the country’s financial regulator.
Local branches of overseas banks will be allowed to hold contracts equivalent to no more than 200 percent of their equity capital, down from 250 percent currently, and the cap for domestic banks will be cut to 40 percent from 50 percent, said the Financial Supervisory Service official, who declined to be identified because the plan isn’t public yet. The finance ministry will announce the changes in January, he said.
Nations from China to South Africa are striving to limit currency volatility as near-zero borrowing costs in the U.S. and Japan spur demand for higher-yielding assets in emerging-markets. South Korea’s existing limits on banks’ use of currency derivatives took effect in October and are subject to review every three months.
“They’re obviously concerned about trying to control capital inflows and limit the impact this could have on the currency,” said Brian Jackson, Hong Kong-based senior strategist at Royal Bank of Canada. “But I’m a little bit skeptical that this is a really big deal. I think it’s already been pretty well-flagged in advance and the market has sort of accepted that there are going to be a few limited measures.”
The Korea Economic Daily newspaper reported the planned tightening two days ago, citing unidentified officials at the finance ministry and the Bank of Korea, and said the new limits on derivatives holdings will probably take effect in March.
Limited Impact
The planned changes aren’t expected to have much impact as foreign banks’ local branches currently have contracts totaling no more than 150 percent of their equity capital and domestic banks’ holdings are 10 percent or less, the Financial Supervisory Service official said. Exporter demand for currency- hedging products is also unlikely to be affected, he said.
The government earlier this month said it will impose a levy on banks’ foreign-exchange borrowings to help curb capital flows. The National Assembly on Dec. 8 passed a bill that will from Jan. 1 restore taxes on foreign investors’ holdings of the nation’s bonds.
The Korean won rose 0.1 percent today to close at 1,146.35 per dollar in Seoul, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The currency has gained 1.5 percent so far this year and, according to analysts surveyed by Bloomberg, will gain 9.2 percent by the end of 2011.
To contact the reporter on this story: Seonjin Cha in Seoul at scha2@bloomberg.net Frances Yoon in Seoul at fyoon2@bloomberg.net.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Philip Lagerkranser at lagerkranser@bloomberg.net Sandy Hendry at shendry@bloomberg.net.
Local branches of overseas banks will be allowed to hold contracts equivalent to no more than 200 percent of their equity capital, down from 250 percent currently, and the cap for domestic banks will be cut to 40 percent from 50 percent, said the Financial Supervisory Service official, who declined to be identified because the plan isn’t public yet. The finance ministry will announce the changes in January, he said.
Nations from China to South Africa are striving to limit currency volatility as near-zero borrowing costs in the U.S. and Japan spur demand for higher-yielding assets in emerging-markets. South Korea’s existing limits on banks’ use of currency derivatives took effect in October and are subject to review every three months.
“They’re obviously concerned about trying to control capital inflows and limit the impact this could have on the currency,” said Brian Jackson, Hong Kong-based senior strategist at Royal Bank of Canada. “But I’m a little bit skeptical that this is a really big deal. I think it’s already been pretty well-flagged in advance and the market has sort of accepted that there are going to be a few limited measures.”
The Korea Economic Daily newspaper reported the planned tightening two days ago, citing unidentified officials at the finance ministry and the Bank of Korea, and said the new limits on derivatives holdings will probably take effect in March.
Limited Impact
The planned changes aren’t expected to have much impact as foreign banks’ local branches currently have contracts totaling no more than 150 percent of their equity capital and domestic banks’ holdings are 10 percent or less, the Financial Supervisory Service official said. Exporter demand for currency- hedging products is also unlikely to be affected, he said.
The government earlier this month said it will impose a levy on banks’ foreign-exchange borrowings to help curb capital flows. The National Assembly on Dec. 8 passed a bill that will from Jan. 1 restore taxes on foreign investors’ holdings of the nation’s bonds.
The Korean won rose 0.1 percent today to close at 1,146.35 per dollar in Seoul, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The currency has gained 1.5 percent so far this year and, according to analysts surveyed by Bloomberg, will gain 9.2 percent by the end of 2011.
To contact the reporter on this story: Seonjin Cha in Seoul at scha2@bloomberg.net Frances Yoon in Seoul at fyoon2@bloomberg.net.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Philip Lagerkranser at lagerkranser@bloomberg.net Sandy Hendry at shendry@bloomberg.net.
Indonesia Tightens Rules on Foreign Exchange Holdings, Overseas Borrowing
Indonesia said it will tighten rules on banks’ foreign-exchange holdings and overseas borrowing to cope with capital inflows that have pushed up inflation and strengthened the rupiah this year.
Bank Indonesia will also reintroduce a 30 percent cap on lenders’ short-term overseas borrowing to minimize the risk of sudden capital outflows, it said yesterday. Banks must set aside 5 percent of their total foreign-exchange holdings as reserves as of March 2011, from 1 percent currently, Deputy Governor Budi Mulya said at a press briefing in Jakarta yesterday. The reserve requirement will rise to 8 percent effective June.
“These rules will ease pressure on the rupiah,” said Anton Gunawan, chief economist at Jakarta-based PT Bank Danamon Indonesia. “The central bank wants to absorb excess liquidity in the banking system.”
Indonesia and its peers are grappling with increasing capital inflows as borrowing costs and growth rates that are higher than those of developed economies boost the appeal of emerging-market assets. Taiwan tightened curbs on exchange-rate derivatives this week and South Korea plans similar measures, according to an official at the country’s financial regulator.
The rupiah rose to a one-month high today, helped by demand for higher-yielding assets. The currency climbed 0.3 percent to 8,973 per dollar as of 11:12 a.m. in Jakarta, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. That’s the strongest level since Nov. 29.
Delayed Impact
The steps by the central bank “will be implemented in March; that is why it is not having an impact on the currency,” said Lindawati Susanto, head of foreign-exchange trading at PT Bank Resona Perdania in Jakarta. “The liquidity will be drying up next year.”
The benchmark Jakarta Composite Index of stocks has surged 47 percent in the past year and was up 0.4 percent at 11:24 a.m. today. It is among the top 10 performing equity indices in the world this year, together with those in Sri Lanka, Peru, Thailand and the Philippines.
Bank Indonesia has resisted imposing capital controls or raising its benchmark interest rate from a record-low 6.5 percent, choosing instead to increase bank reserve requirements and encourage investors to keep their money in the country for longer periods.
The current benchmark rate is consistent with Indonesia’s goal of achieving inflation of 4 percent to 6 percent in 2011 and 3.5 percent to 5.5 percent in 2012, Mulya said yesterday.
Absorb Liquidity
The higher foreign-exchange reserve ratios may absorb as much as $3 billion in excess liquidity, and are “prudent banking” measures aimed at helping Southeast Asia’s largest economy cope with capital inflows, Mulya said.
“If money is pulled into the reserve requirement then it cannot circulate within the system,” said Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa, an economist at PT Danareksa Research Institute in Jakarta. “That’s a disincentive to avoid banks attracting too much dollar since they must pay interest on that dollar whereas the money is put away at Bank Indonesia, which may not even earn interest.”
Lenders will be required to limit their short-term overseas borrowing to no more than 30 percent of their capital starting in January, the central bank said. The rule aims to encourage a shift to long-term foreign borrowing and reduce the risk of sudden reversals in capital flows, it said. The requirement was scrapped in 2008 because of the global financial crisis.
Korea, Taiwan
South Korea plans to tighten curbs on banks’ holdings of foreign-exchange derivatives, lowering existing limits by a fifth, according to an official at the Financial Supervisory Service, who declined to be identified because the plan isn’t public yet. The finance ministry will announce the changes in January, he said.
Taiwan’s curbs on derivatives will help to combat currency speculation by foreigners, the central bank said this week. The island last month also restricted offshore funds to investing no more than 30 percent of their portfolios in local government debt and money-market products.
Five state-owned Indonesian financial institutions, including PT Bank Mandiri, have given their commitment to buy back bonds to ease the impact of sudden capital outflows during a crisis, Agus Suprijanto, acting head of fiscal policy at the Finance Ministry, said this week. The government is still in talks over the use of their funds and will prioritize funding from the state budget for any buybacks, he added.
Indonesia will also require lenders with assets of at least 10 trillion rupiah ($1 billion) to announce their prime lending rates, effective in March 2011. This rule will push banks to decrease their net interest margin and become more efficient, the central bank said. Lending growth may reach 22 percent this year, it said.
To contact the reporter on this story: Novrida Manurung in Jakarta at nmanurung@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Chris Anstey at canstey@bloomberg.net; Greg Ahlstrand at gahlstrand@bloomberg.net
Bank Indonesia will also reintroduce a 30 percent cap on lenders’ short-term overseas borrowing to minimize the risk of sudden capital outflows, it said yesterday. Banks must set aside 5 percent of their total foreign-exchange holdings as reserves as of March 2011, from 1 percent currently, Deputy Governor Budi Mulya said at a press briefing in Jakarta yesterday. The reserve requirement will rise to 8 percent effective June.
“These rules will ease pressure on the rupiah,” said Anton Gunawan, chief economist at Jakarta-based PT Bank Danamon Indonesia. “The central bank wants to absorb excess liquidity in the banking system.”
Indonesia and its peers are grappling with increasing capital inflows as borrowing costs and growth rates that are higher than those of developed economies boost the appeal of emerging-market assets. Taiwan tightened curbs on exchange-rate derivatives this week and South Korea plans similar measures, according to an official at the country’s financial regulator.
The rupiah rose to a one-month high today, helped by demand for higher-yielding assets. The currency climbed 0.3 percent to 8,973 per dollar as of 11:12 a.m. in Jakarta, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. That’s the strongest level since Nov. 29.
Delayed Impact
The steps by the central bank “will be implemented in March; that is why it is not having an impact on the currency,” said Lindawati Susanto, head of foreign-exchange trading at PT Bank Resona Perdania in Jakarta. “The liquidity will be drying up next year.”
The benchmark Jakarta Composite Index of stocks has surged 47 percent in the past year and was up 0.4 percent at 11:24 a.m. today. It is among the top 10 performing equity indices in the world this year, together with those in Sri Lanka, Peru, Thailand and the Philippines.
Bank Indonesia has resisted imposing capital controls or raising its benchmark interest rate from a record-low 6.5 percent, choosing instead to increase bank reserve requirements and encourage investors to keep their money in the country for longer periods.
The current benchmark rate is consistent with Indonesia’s goal of achieving inflation of 4 percent to 6 percent in 2011 and 3.5 percent to 5.5 percent in 2012, Mulya said yesterday.
Absorb Liquidity
The higher foreign-exchange reserve ratios may absorb as much as $3 billion in excess liquidity, and are “prudent banking” measures aimed at helping Southeast Asia’s largest economy cope with capital inflows, Mulya said.
“If money is pulled into the reserve requirement then it cannot circulate within the system,” said Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa, an economist at PT Danareksa Research Institute in Jakarta. “That’s a disincentive to avoid banks attracting too much dollar since they must pay interest on that dollar whereas the money is put away at Bank Indonesia, which may not even earn interest.”
Lenders will be required to limit their short-term overseas borrowing to no more than 30 percent of their capital starting in January, the central bank said. The rule aims to encourage a shift to long-term foreign borrowing and reduce the risk of sudden reversals in capital flows, it said. The requirement was scrapped in 2008 because of the global financial crisis.
Korea, Taiwan
South Korea plans to tighten curbs on banks’ holdings of foreign-exchange derivatives, lowering existing limits by a fifth, according to an official at the Financial Supervisory Service, who declined to be identified because the plan isn’t public yet. The finance ministry will announce the changes in January, he said.
Taiwan’s curbs on derivatives will help to combat currency speculation by foreigners, the central bank said this week. The island last month also restricted offshore funds to investing no more than 30 percent of their portfolios in local government debt and money-market products.
Five state-owned Indonesian financial institutions, including PT Bank Mandiri, have given their commitment to buy back bonds to ease the impact of sudden capital outflows during a crisis, Agus Suprijanto, acting head of fiscal policy at the Finance Ministry, said this week. The government is still in talks over the use of their funds and will prioritize funding from the state budget for any buybacks, he added.
Indonesia will also require lenders with assets of at least 10 trillion rupiah ($1 billion) to announce their prime lending rates, effective in March 2011. This rule will push banks to decrease their net interest margin and become more efficient, the central bank said. Lending growth may reach 22 percent this year, it said.
To contact the reporter on this story: Novrida Manurung in Jakarta at nmanurung@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Chris Anstey at canstey@bloomberg.net; Greg Ahlstrand at gahlstrand@bloomberg.net
China Manufacturing Growth Slows as Policy Tightened
China’s manufacturing growth slowed for the first time in five months in December as the government tightened monetary policy and chased energy- efficiency and pollution targets, a survey indicated.
A purchasing managers’ index released today by HSBC Holdings Plc and Markit Economics fell to 54.4 from 55.3 in November. The data are seasonally adjusted and a reading above 50 indicates an expansion.
Rising corporate profits and expansions by companies including Aluminum Corp of China Ltd. and Volkswagen AG may help to sustain manufacturing as the government curbs lending to counter inflation.
Morgan Stanley and JPMorgan Chase & Co. forecast interest rates will rise at least twice in the first half of 2011 after an increase on Christmas Day that was the second since the global financial crisis.
“Inflation rather than growth still remains as the top policy concern, despite the moderation in December’s manufacturing PMI reading,” said Qu Hongbin, Hong Kong-based China economist for HSBC. “Modest” interest-rate increases are needed to anchor inflation expectations in coming months, Qu said.
The Shanghai Composite Index fell 0.4 percent as of the 11:30 a.m. local time break in trading. The yuan touched 6.6142 per dollar, the strongest since 1993.
Switch From Contraction
While today’s PMI reading was the weakest in three months, it compares with a contraction as recently as July. For the fourth quarter as a whole, the index had the strongest performance since the first three months of this year, HSBC said in a statement.
The measure is based on a survey of executives at more than 430 companies and gives an indication of activity in the manufacturing sector. A separate government-backed PMI is due Jan. 1.
Higher interest rates, a crackdown on real-estate speculation, and closures of energy-wasting and highly polluting factories are among measures by Premier Wen Jiabao’s government that may cool growth. Officials have also boosted reserve requirements for lenders six times this year to counter inflation and limit asset bubbles in the real- estate market.
Export Orders
New export orders rose “only modestly,” indicating that growth centered on the domestic market, the bank said, without giving numbers.
The report contained some encouraging signs for policy makers, with input and output costs rising at a slower pace and job creation quickening to the fastest since June, HSBC said. Still, the inflation measures remain elevated, the bank said.
Today’s data “suggests industrial production momentum is still strong, though sentiment may have been weakened a bit by recent tightening measures and companies’ lingering concern over how such tightening is going to play out,” said Li Wei, Shanghai-based economist with Standard Chartered Bank.
Industrial companies’ profits climbed 49 percent in the first 11 months of 2010 to 3.88 trillion yuan ($585 billion), according to a Dec. 27 government report.
The economy grew 9.6 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier. Consumer prices climbed 5.1 percent in November from a year earlier, the most in 28 months, and producer prices gained 6.1 percent.
Inflation Fight
Peng Sen, vice chairman of the National Development and Reform Commission, said the nation must prepare for a long- term fight against inflation, according to a Dec. 21 report on state television.
Companies in China, the world’s biggest maker of steel, cement and mobile phones, are expanding after exports topped pre-crisis levels. The momentum of economic growth is “consolidating,” the central bank said Dec. 27.
Aluminum Corp. of China, or Chalco, will build a 17.5 billion yuan base that includes alumina and aluminum smelting plants and a bauxite mine in the southwestern Guizhou province, according to a statement in the government-run People’s Daily newspaper.
German carmaker VW’s two joint ventures in China will spend 10.6 billion euros ($14 billion) in the world’s biggest auto market through 2015, adding two factories to help double production to 3 million cars a year, the company said last month.
--Zheng Lifei. With assistance from Sophie Leung in Hong Kong and Li Yanping in Beijing. Editors: Paul Panckhurst, Ken McCallum
To contact Bloomberg News staff for this story: Zheng Lifei in Beijing at +86-10-6649-7560 or lzheng32@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Chris Anstey at canstey@bloomberg.net
A purchasing managers’ index released today by HSBC Holdings Plc and Markit Economics fell to 54.4 from 55.3 in November. The data are seasonally adjusted and a reading above 50 indicates an expansion.
Rising corporate profits and expansions by companies including Aluminum Corp of China Ltd. and Volkswagen AG may help to sustain manufacturing as the government curbs lending to counter inflation.
Morgan Stanley and JPMorgan Chase & Co. forecast interest rates will rise at least twice in the first half of 2011 after an increase on Christmas Day that was the second since the global financial crisis.
“Inflation rather than growth still remains as the top policy concern, despite the moderation in December’s manufacturing PMI reading,” said Qu Hongbin, Hong Kong-based China economist for HSBC. “Modest” interest-rate increases are needed to anchor inflation expectations in coming months, Qu said.
The Shanghai Composite Index fell 0.4 percent as of the 11:30 a.m. local time break in trading. The yuan touched 6.6142 per dollar, the strongest since 1993.
Switch From Contraction
While today’s PMI reading was the weakest in three months, it compares with a contraction as recently as July. For the fourth quarter as a whole, the index had the strongest performance since the first three months of this year, HSBC said in a statement.
The measure is based on a survey of executives at more than 430 companies and gives an indication of activity in the manufacturing sector. A separate government-backed PMI is due Jan. 1.
Higher interest rates, a crackdown on real-estate speculation, and closures of energy-wasting and highly polluting factories are among measures by Premier Wen Jiabao’s government that may cool growth. Officials have also boosted reserve requirements for lenders six times this year to counter inflation and limit asset bubbles in the real- estate market.
Export Orders
New export orders rose “only modestly,” indicating that growth centered on the domestic market, the bank said, without giving numbers.
The report contained some encouraging signs for policy makers, with input and output costs rising at a slower pace and job creation quickening to the fastest since June, HSBC said. Still, the inflation measures remain elevated, the bank said.
Today’s data “suggests industrial production momentum is still strong, though sentiment may have been weakened a bit by recent tightening measures and companies’ lingering concern over how such tightening is going to play out,” said Li Wei, Shanghai-based economist with Standard Chartered Bank.
Industrial companies’ profits climbed 49 percent in the first 11 months of 2010 to 3.88 trillion yuan ($585 billion), according to a Dec. 27 government report.
The economy grew 9.6 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier. Consumer prices climbed 5.1 percent in November from a year earlier, the most in 28 months, and producer prices gained 6.1 percent.
Inflation Fight
Peng Sen, vice chairman of the National Development and Reform Commission, said the nation must prepare for a long- term fight against inflation, according to a Dec. 21 report on state television.
Companies in China, the world’s biggest maker of steel, cement and mobile phones, are expanding after exports topped pre-crisis levels. The momentum of economic growth is “consolidating,” the central bank said Dec. 27.
Aluminum Corp. of China, or Chalco, will build a 17.5 billion yuan base that includes alumina and aluminum smelting plants and a bauxite mine in the southwestern Guizhou province, according to a statement in the government-run People’s Daily newspaper.
German carmaker VW’s two joint ventures in China will spend 10.6 billion euros ($14 billion) in the world’s biggest auto market through 2015, adding two factories to help double production to 3 million cars a year, the company said last month.
--Zheng Lifei. With assistance from Sophie Leung in Hong Kong and Li Yanping in Beijing. Editors: Paul Panckhurst, Ken McCallum
To contact Bloomberg News staff for this story: Zheng Lifei in Beijing at +86-10-6649-7560 or lzheng32@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Chris Anstey at canstey@bloomberg.net
Dodging Repatriation Tax Lets Companies Bring Home Cash
At the White House on Dec. 15, business executives asked President Obama for a tax holiday that would help them tap more than $1 trillion of offshore earnings, much of it sitting in island tax havens.
The money -- including hundreds of billions in profits that U.S. companies attribute to overseas subsidiaries to avoid taxes -- is supposed to be taxed at up to 35 percent when it’s brought home, or “repatriated.”
Executives including John T. Chambers of Cisco Systems Inc. say a tax break would return a flood of cash and boost the economy.
What nobody’s saying publicly is that U.S. multinationals are already finding legal ways to avoid that tax. Over the years, they’ve brought cash home, tax-free, employing strategies with nicknames worthy of 1970s conspiracy thrillers -- including “the Killer B” and “the Deadly D.”
Merck & Co Inc., the second-largest drugmaker in the U.S., last year brought more than $9 billion from abroad without paying any U.S. tax to help finance its acquisition of Schering-Plough Corp., securities filings show. Merck is also appealing a federal judge’s 2009 finding that Schering-Plough owed taxes on $690 million it had earlier brought home from overseas tax-free.
The largest drugmaker, Pfizer Inc., imported more than $30 billion from offshore in connection with its acquisition of Wyeth last year, while taking steps to minimize the tax hit on its publicly reported profit.
Disclosures in Switzerland and Delaware by Eli Lilly & Co. show the Indianapolis-based pharmaceutical company carried out many of the steps for a tax-free importation of foreign cash after its roughly $6 billion purchase of ImClone Systems Inc. in 2008.
‘Trivially Small Taxes’
“Sophisticated U.S. companies are routinely repatriating hundreds of billions of dollars in foreign earnings and paying trivially small U.S. taxes on those repatriations,” said Edward D. Kleinbard, a law professor at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles. “They devote enormous resources first to moving income to tax havens, and then to bringing those profits back to the U.S. at the lowest possible tax cost.”
With the exception of the Schering-Plough case, no authority has accused Merck or Pfizer or Lilly of paying less tax than they should have. While corporations have no obligation to pay any more than the legal minimum, “the question is what should that minimum be?” said Kleinbard, a former corporate tax attorney at Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP and former chief of staff at the congressional Joint Committee on Taxation.
U.S. companies overall use various repatriation strategies to avoid about $25 billion a year in federal income taxes, he said.
‘Best of Worlds’
“The current U.S. international tax system is the best of all worlds for U.S. multinationals,” said David S. Miller, a partner at Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft LLP in New York. That’s because the companies can defer federal income taxes by shifting profits into low-tax jurisdictions abroad, and then use foreign tax credits to shelter those earnings from U.S. tax when they repatriate them, he said.
They’re aided by a cadre of attorneys, accountants and investment bankers in the tax-planning industry -- such as a panel of KPMG LLP tax advisers who held forth in a chilly hotel ballroom at a Philadelphia conference last month. There, they discussed a series of techniques for multinationals to return cash from overseas while avoiding or deferring the taxes.
KPMG tax advisers Kevin Glenn and Tom Zollo used slides to describe several methods. One diagram resembled a schematic from the Manhattan Project. Another strategy would require certain “bells and whistles” to convince regulators of an actual non-tax business purpose, Glenn explained.
Cat and Mouse
Such maneuvers reflect a decades-long cat-and-mouse game. As regulators and lawmakers tighten the rules, companies seek new, legal methods for getting around them. One of the techniques the KPMG advisers discussed was in response to loophole-closers Congress passed in August to address a projected $1.4 trillion federal budget deficit. The changes will make it harder for companies to manipulate the credits they get for taxes paid overseas.
“Some of the best minds in the country are spent all day, every day, wheedling nickels and dimes out of the tax system,” said H. David Rosenbloom, an attorney at Caplin & Drysdale in Washington, D.C., and director of the international tax program at New York University’s school of law.
Chambers, Cisco’s chief executive officer, brought up a repatriation break during the White House meeting, according to a person familiar with the discussion. It could reprise a 2004 tax holiday that allowed multinationals to return profits to the U.S. at a tax rate of 5.25 percent. U.S. corporations brought home $362 billion, with $312 billion qualifying for the relief, according to the Internal Revenue Service.
Short-Term Fix
Such a move “is a short-term fix to a long-term problem, which is the uncompetitive U.S. tax structure,” said Cisco spokeswoman Jennifer Greeson Dunn. The San Jose, California-based company reported $31.6 billion of undistributed foreign earnings, on which it had paid no U.S. taxes, as of July 31.
President Obama, who campaigned in part against companies’ use of offshore havens to avoid U.S. taxes, asked Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner to follow up on the issue with business leaders, according to a White House official who asked not to be identified because the discussions were private.
The argument that a new tax break for offshore earnings would generate a domestic stimulus “holds no water at all,” said Joel B. Slemrod, an economics professor at the University of Michigan’s school of business and former senior tax economist for President Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisers. U.S. companies are already sitting on a record pile of cash -- $1.9 trillion in liquid assets, according to Federal Reserve data.
‘Cash Hoards’
“The fact that they have these cash hoards suggests that investment is not being constrained by lack of cash,” Slemrod said.
U.S. multinationals boost earnings by shifting income out of the country via transfer pricing, a system that allows them to allocate costs to subsidiaries in high-tax countries and profits to tax havens. Google Inc., for example, cut its taxes by $3.1 billion in the last three years by moving most of the income it attributed overseas ultimately to Bermuda, Bloomberg News reported in October.
The tax benefits from such profit shifting can have a greater impact on share price than boosting sales or cutting other expenses, since the reduced rate goes straight to the bottom line, said John P. Kennedy, a partner at Deloitte Tax LLP, speaking at the conference in Philadelphia Nov. 3.
Boosting Share Prices
For a hypothetical company that has 1,000 shares outstanding, has pretax income of $5,000 and trades at 20 times earnings, cutting just 2 percentage points off the rate could drive the share price up $2, Kennedy said.
“You may think two bucks isn’t much, but when you’re the CFO and she has 100,000 options, that’s pretty interesting,” he said. He cited large pharmaceutical and biotech companies, including Merck, Amgen Inc. and Eli Lilly, which have reported effective income tax rates at least 10 percentage points below the statutory 35 percent rate.
The bottom line: The effective tax rate “is, and will continue to be, the metric that is used to judge your performance,” he told the audience of corporate tax accountants and attorneys.
U.S. drugmakers shift profits overseas far in excess of actual sales there. In 2008, large U.S. pharmaceutical
companies reported about four-fifths of their pre-tax income abroad, up from about a third in 1997, according to a March article in the journal Tax Notes by Martin A. Sullivan, a contributing editor and former U.S. Treasury Department tax economist. Their actual foreign sales grew more slowly, to 52 percent from 38 percent.
Stranded Cash
Deloitte’s Kennedy warned that booking large portions of income overseas can mean “you are going to strand so much cash offshore that your business chokes.” That’s because the foreign profits cannot be used for such purposes as building domestic factories without triggering federal tax. Overall, U.S. companies reported more than $1 trillion in such “indefinitely reinvested earnings” offshore at the end of 2009, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Last year, Merck, based in Whitehouse Station, New Jersey, tapped its offshore cash, tax-free, to pay for just over half the cash portion of its $51 billion merger with Schering-Plough, according to company filings.
At the deal’s closing, Merck’s foreign subsidiaries lent $9.4 billion to a pair of Schering-Plough Dutch units. Then the Dutch companies used those funds to repay a pre-existing loan from their U.S. parent, securities filings show. The $9.4 billion ended up with Schering-Plough shareholders as part of the cash owed under the merger, according to the company’s disclosure.
No Tax Hit
Bottom line: Merck used its overseas cash to pay the former Schering-Plough shareholders -- with no U.S. tax hit. In considering whether companies owe taxes in such cases, the IRS often asks whether payments from an offshore unit constitute a dividend, which would be taxable.
In Merck’s case, it arguably could be, said Robert Willens, who runs an independent firm that advises investors on tax issues.
“Merck was obligated to pay Schering-Plough shareholders and they tapped into the funds of their overseas subsidiaries to do it,” he said. “You’d have to be concerned about a constructive dividend there.”
Merck objected to any characterization of the payment as a dividend. “We don’t think the characterization is accurate and we remain confident with our tax position,” said Steven Campanini, a company spokesman.
On Appeal
In the Schering-Plough case decided last year, the drugmaker brought home $690 million tax-free as a result of assigning its rights to income from a complex interest-rate swap to a foreign subsidiary in the 1990s. A judge found the company “failed to establish a genuine purpose for the transactions other than tax avoidance” and said Schering-Plough was not entitled to $473 million in back taxes in dispute. Merck is appealing the judgment.
Even when companies pay large tax bills to import their foreign profits, they find ways to minimize the impact on the earnings they show investors. Last year, New York-based Pfizer repatriated more than $30 billion from offshore to help pay for its $64 billion purchase of Wyeth, according to company disclosures and a person familiar with the transaction.
The acquisition created a so-called deferred tax liability on Pfizer’s balance sheet of about $25 billion, according to securities filings, in part to allow for an anticipated tax hit on the earnings that would be repatriated.
Impact Wiped Out
While bringing home more than $30 billion helped generate a $10 billion tax obligation, Pfizer was able to draw down $10 billion of its new deferred liability through its income statement. Doing so wiped out the tax impact of the repatriation on its earnings reported to shareholders.
So while the company paid a real tax bill to the U.S. government stemming from the repatriation, that tax payment had limited impact on its publicly reported profits.
Pfizer made use of a legal accounting quirk that allowed it to set up the deferred liability on its balance sheet, but reverse part of that liability through its income statement, said Edmund Outslay, a professor of tax accounting at Michigan State University.
“Had Pfizer repatriated these earnings independently of the purchase of Wyeth, it would have incurred a huge tax charge” on its income statement, Outslay said. “So through the magic of purchase accounting, you create an opportunity to bring this money home while mitigating its impact on your effective tax rate.”
Effective Tax Rate
Pfizer spokeswoman Joan Campion said the $10 billion tax hit was indeed erased on the income statement because of the accounting treatment, but noted that the company’s effective tax rate rose in 2009 in part because Wyeth’s overseas profits were repatriated to help finance the deal.
Other strategies based on acquisitions have achieved nickname status among corporate tax advisers.
The “Killer B” maneuver is named for section 368(a)(1)(B) of the Internal Revenue Code, which deals with tax-free reorganizations. A U.S. company using the technique would sell its shares to an offshore subsidiary, bringing cash back to the U.S. tax-free. The offshore unit could then use the stock to make an acquisition. In 2006, the IRS issued a notice aimed at shutting down the maneuver.
Using a Variation
International Business Machines Corp. used a variation on the technique in May 2007, with an offshore unit purchasing the shares from a trio of banks, according to a company securities filing. That permutation wasn’t covered by the IRS in 2006. Two days after IBM’s disclosure, the agency announced plans for additional rule changes addressing stock sales to subsidiaries from shareholders as well as directly from parent companies.
The “Deadly D,” also named for a section of tax law, allows a U.S. company to attach the high tax basis in a newly acquired company to one of its existing foreign units. In some cases, doing so enables the U.S. parent to pull cash from the subsidiary up to the amount of the recent purchase price tax-free. The Obama administration has proposed changing the provision that enables the maneuver.
Lilly closed on its purchase of ImClone in November 2008. The next month, the newly acquired company converted to an LLC and Lilly transferred the investment to its main Swiss subsidiary, Eli Lilly SA, according to disclosures in Switzerland and Delaware. The transfer was in exchange for a $5.8 billion note payable to the U.S. parent company due at the end of 2011.
Extracting Earnings
Willens, the independent tax adviser, said the steps indicated a likely D reorganization, or another method “to extract earnings from overseas without tax consequences -- of course.” Lilly had no comment beyond its filings, said David P. Lewis, the company’s vice president for global taxes.
The KPMG panel discussion in Philadelphia, called “Global Cash Tax Management Plans and Repatriation Planning,” dissected other techniques, including one that took six slides to explain. It works like this:
Soon after a U.S. multinational has purchased another U.S. company, the new unit promises to pay the parent a large amount of cash pursuant to a note agreement. Since both parties are U.S. companies, there is no tax bill for the parent under current U.S. law.
Then the new acquisition converts to a foreign company. So when the payment pursuant to the note is made, it comes from overseas. That means the foreign cash is treated as a nontaxable payment under the note, instead of a taxable dividend.
Going Offshore
The newly converted foreign subsidiary could access the multinational’s existing offshore cash by borrowing from a foreign sister unit, said Glenn, the KPMG tax partner. He and Zollo were joined by colleague Frank Mattei, as well as Don Whitt, a Pfizer tax official.
“This basic transaction is something that at least a couple of taxpayers have done, and I know a number of others have evaluated,” Glenn said. The strategy’s name follows the alphabetic tradition of Bs and Ds. It’s called “the Outbound F.”
To contact the reporter on this story: Jesse Drucker in New York at jdrucker4@bloomberg.net.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Gary Putka at gputka@bloomberg.net.
The money -- including hundreds of billions in profits that U.S. companies attribute to overseas subsidiaries to avoid taxes -- is supposed to be taxed at up to 35 percent when it’s brought home, or “repatriated.”
Executives including John T. Chambers of Cisco Systems Inc. say a tax break would return a flood of cash and boost the economy.
What nobody’s saying publicly is that U.S. multinationals are already finding legal ways to avoid that tax. Over the years, they’ve brought cash home, tax-free, employing strategies with nicknames worthy of 1970s conspiracy thrillers -- including “the Killer B” and “the Deadly D.”
Merck & Co Inc., the second-largest drugmaker in the U.S., last year brought more than $9 billion from abroad without paying any U.S. tax to help finance its acquisition of Schering-Plough Corp., securities filings show. Merck is also appealing a federal judge’s 2009 finding that Schering-Plough owed taxes on $690 million it had earlier brought home from overseas tax-free.
The largest drugmaker, Pfizer Inc., imported more than $30 billion from offshore in connection with its acquisition of Wyeth last year, while taking steps to minimize the tax hit on its publicly reported profit.
Disclosures in Switzerland and Delaware by Eli Lilly & Co. show the Indianapolis-based pharmaceutical company carried out many of the steps for a tax-free importation of foreign cash after its roughly $6 billion purchase of ImClone Systems Inc. in 2008.
‘Trivially Small Taxes’
“Sophisticated U.S. companies are routinely repatriating hundreds of billions of dollars in foreign earnings and paying trivially small U.S. taxes on those repatriations,” said Edward D. Kleinbard, a law professor at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles. “They devote enormous resources first to moving income to tax havens, and then to bringing those profits back to the U.S. at the lowest possible tax cost.”
With the exception of the Schering-Plough case, no authority has accused Merck or Pfizer or Lilly of paying less tax than they should have. While corporations have no obligation to pay any more than the legal minimum, “the question is what should that minimum be?” said Kleinbard, a former corporate tax attorney at Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP and former chief of staff at the congressional Joint Committee on Taxation.
U.S. companies overall use various repatriation strategies to avoid about $25 billion a year in federal income taxes, he said.
‘Best of Worlds’
“The current U.S. international tax system is the best of all worlds for U.S. multinationals,” said David S. Miller, a partner at Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft LLP in New York. That’s because the companies can defer federal income taxes by shifting profits into low-tax jurisdictions abroad, and then use foreign tax credits to shelter those earnings from U.S. tax when they repatriate them, he said.
They’re aided by a cadre of attorneys, accountants and investment bankers in the tax-planning industry -- such as a panel of KPMG LLP tax advisers who held forth in a chilly hotel ballroom at a Philadelphia conference last month. There, they discussed a series of techniques for multinationals to return cash from overseas while avoiding or deferring the taxes.
KPMG tax advisers Kevin Glenn and Tom Zollo used slides to describe several methods. One diagram resembled a schematic from the Manhattan Project. Another strategy would require certain “bells and whistles” to convince regulators of an actual non-tax business purpose, Glenn explained.
Cat and Mouse
Such maneuvers reflect a decades-long cat-and-mouse game. As regulators and lawmakers tighten the rules, companies seek new, legal methods for getting around them. One of the techniques the KPMG advisers discussed was in response to loophole-closers Congress passed in August to address a projected $1.4 trillion federal budget deficit. The changes will make it harder for companies to manipulate the credits they get for taxes paid overseas.
“Some of the best minds in the country are spent all day, every day, wheedling nickels and dimes out of the tax system,” said H. David Rosenbloom, an attorney at Caplin & Drysdale in Washington, D.C., and director of the international tax program at New York University’s school of law.
Chambers, Cisco’s chief executive officer, brought up a repatriation break during the White House meeting, according to a person familiar with the discussion. It could reprise a 2004 tax holiday that allowed multinationals to return profits to the U.S. at a tax rate of 5.25 percent. U.S. corporations brought home $362 billion, with $312 billion qualifying for the relief, according to the Internal Revenue Service.
Short-Term Fix
Such a move “is a short-term fix to a long-term problem, which is the uncompetitive U.S. tax structure,” said Cisco spokeswoman Jennifer Greeson Dunn. The San Jose, California-based company reported $31.6 billion of undistributed foreign earnings, on which it had paid no U.S. taxes, as of July 31.
President Obama, who campaigned in part against companies’ use of offshore havens to avoid U.S. taxes, asked Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner to follow up on the issue with business leaders, according to a White House official who asked not to be identified because the discussions were private.
The argument that a new tax break for offshore earnings would generate a domestic stimulus “holds no water at all,” said Joel B. Slemrod, an economics professor at the University of Michigan’s school of business and former senior tax economist for President Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisers. U.S. companies are already sitting on a record pile of cash -- $1.9 trillion in liquid assets, according to Federal Reserve data.
‘Cash Hoards’
“The fact that they have these cash hoards suggests that investment is not being constrained by lack of cash,” Slemrod said.
U.S. multinationals boost earnings by shifting income out of the country via transfer pricing, a system that allows them to allocate costs to subsidiaries in high-tax countries and profits to tax havens. Google Inc., for example, cut its taxes by $3.1 billion in the last three years by moving most of the income it attributed overseas ultimately to Bermuda, Bloomberg News reported in October.
The tax benefits from such profit shifting can have a greater impact on share price than boosting sales or cutting other expenses, since the reduced rate goes straight to the bottom line, said John P. Kennedy, a partner at Deloitte Tax LLP, speaking at the conference in Philadelphia Nov. 3.
Boosting Share Prices
For a hypothetical company that has 1,000 shares outstanding, has pretax income of $5,000 and trades at 20 times earnings, cutting just 2 percentage points off the rate could drive the share price up $2, Kennedy said.
“You may think two bucks isn’t much, but when you’re the CFO and she has 100,000 options, that’s pretty interesting,” he said. He cited large pharmaceutical and biotech companies, including Merck, Amgen Inc. and Eli Lilly, which have reported effective income tax rates at least 10 percentage points below the statutory 35 percent rate.
The bottom line: The effective tax rate “is, and will continue to be, the metric that is used to judge your performance,” he told the audience of corporate tax accountants and attorneys.
U.S. drugmakers shift profits overseas far in excess of actual sales there. In 2008, large U.S. pharmaceutical
companies reported about four-fifths of their pre-tax income abroad, up from about a third in 1997, according to a March article in the journal Tax Notes by Martin A. Sullivan, a contributing editor and former U.S. Treasury Department tax economist. Their actual foreign sales grew more slowly, to 52 percent from 38 percent.
Stranded Cash
Deloitte’s Kennedy warned that booking large portions of income overseas can mean “you are going to strand so much cash offshore that your business chokes.” That’s because the foreign profits cannot be used for such purposes as building domestic factories without triggering federal tax. Overall, U.S. companies reported more than $1 trillion in such “indefinitely reinvested earnings” offshore at the end of 2009, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Last year, Merck, based in Whitehouse Station, New Jersey, tapped its offshore cash, tax-free, to pay for just over half the cash portion of its $51 billion merger with Schering-Plough, according to company filings.
At the deal’s closing, Merck’s foreign subsidiaries lent $9.4 billion to a pair of Schering-Plough Dutch units. Then the Dutch companies used those funds to repay a pre-existing loan from their U.S. parent, securities filings show. The $9.4 billion ended up with Schering-Plough shareholders as part of the cash owed under the merger, according to the company’s disclosure.
No Tax Hit
Bottom line: Merck used its overseas cash to pay the former Schering-Plough shareholders -- with no U.S. tax hit. In considering whether companies owe taxes in such cases, the IRS often asks whether payments from an offshore unit constitute a dividend, which would be taxable.
In Merck’s case, it arguably could be, said Robert Willens, who runs an independent firm that advises investors on tax issues.
“Merck was obligated to pay Schering-Plough shareholders and they tapped into the funds of their overseas subsidiaries to do it,” he said. “You’d have to be concerned about a constructive dividend there.”
Merck objected to any characterization of the payment as a dividend. “We don’t think the characterization is accurate and we remain confident with our tax position,” said Steven Campanini, a company spokesman.
On Appeal
In the Schering-Plough case decided last year, the drugmaker brought home $690 million tax-free as a result of assigning its rights to income from a complex interest-rate swap to a foreign subsidiary in the 1990s. A judge found the company “failed to establish a genuine purpose for the transactions other than tax avoidance” and said Schering-Plough was not entitled to $473 million in back taxes in dispute. Merck is appealing the judgment.
Even when companies pay large tax bills to import their foreign profits, they find ways to minimize the impact on the earnings they show investors. Last year, New York-based Pfizer repatriated more than $30 billion from offshore to help pay for its $64 billion purchase of Wyeth, according to company disclosures and a person familiar with the transaction.
The acquisition created a so-called deferred tax liability on Pfizer’s balance sheet of about $25 billion, according to securities filings, in part to allow for an anticipated tax hit on the earnings that would be repatriated.
Impact Wiped Out
While bringing home more than $30 billion helped generate a $10 billion tax obligation, Pfizer was able to draw down $10 billion of its new deferred liability through its income statement. Doing so wiped out the tax impact of the repatriation on its earnings reported to shareholders.
So while the company paid a real tax bill to the U.S. government stemming from the repatriation, that tax payment had limited impact on its publicly reported profits.
Pfizer made use of a legal accounting quirk that allowed it to set up the deferred liability on its balance sheet, but reverse part of that liability through its income statement, said Edmund Outslay, a professor of tax accounting at Michigan State University.
“Had Pfizer repatriated these earnings independently of the purchase of Wyeth, it would have incurred a huge tax charge” on its income statement, Outslay said. “So through the magic of purchase accounting, you create an opportunity to bring this money home while mitigating its impact on your effective tax rate.”
Effective Tax Rate
Pfizer spokeswoman Joan Campion said the $10 billion tax hit was indeed erased on the income statement because of the accounting treatment, but noted that the company’s effective tax rate rose in 2009 in part because Wyeth’s overseas profits were repatriated to help finance the deal.
Other strategies based on acquisitions have achieved nickname status among corporate tax advisers.
The “Killer B” maneuver is named for section 368(a)(1)(B) of the Internal Revenue Code, which deals with tax-free reorganizations. A U.S. company using the technique would sell its shares to an offshore subsidiary, bringing cash back to the U.S. tax-free. The offshore unit could then use the stock to make an acquisition. In 2006, the IRS issued a notice aimed at shutting down the maneuver.
Using a Variation
International Business Machines Corp. used a variation on the technique in May 2007, with an offshore unit purchasing the shares from a trio of banks, according to a company securities filing. That permutation wasn’t covered by the IRS in 2006. Two days after IBM’s disclosure, the agency announced plans for additional rule changes addressing stock sales to subsidiaries from shareholders as well as directly from parent companies.
The “Deadly D,” also named for a section of tax law, allows a U.S. company to attach the high tax basis in a newly acquired company to one of its existing foreign units. In some cases, doing so enables the U.S. parent to pull cash from the subsidiary up to the amount of the recent purchase price tax-free. The Obama administration has proposed changing the provision that enables the maneuver.
Lilly closed on its purchase of ImClone in November 2008. The next month, the newly acquired company converted to an LLC and Lilly transferred the investment to its main Swiss subsidiary, Eli Lilly SA, according to disclosures in Switzerland and Delaware. The transfer was in exchange for a $5.8 billion note payable to the U.S. parent company due at the end of 2011.
Extracting Earnings
Willens, the independent tax adviser, said the steps indicated a likely D reorganization, or another method “to extract earnings from overseas without tax consequences -- of course.” Lilly had no comment beyond its filings, said David P. Lewis, the company’s vice president for global taxes.
The KPMG panel discussion in Philadelphia, called “Global Cash Tax Management Plans and Repatriation Planning,” dissected other techniques, including one that took six slides to explain. It works like this:
Soon after a U.S. multinational has purchased another U.S. company, the new unit promises to pay the parent a large amount of cash pursuant to a note agreement. Since both parties are U.S. companies, there is no tax bill for the parent under current U.S. law.
Then the new acquisition converts to a foreign company. So when the payment pursuant to the note is made, it comes from overseas. That means the foreign cash is treated as a nontaxable payment under the note, instead of a taxable dividend.
Going Offshore
The newly converted foreign subsidiary could access the multinational’s existing offshore cash by borrowing from a foreign sister unit, said Glenn, the KPMG tax partner. He and Zollo were joined by colleague Frank Mattei, as well as Don Whitt, a Pfizer tax official.
“This basic transaction is something that at least a couple of taxpayers have done, and I know a number of others have evaluated,” Glenn said. The strategy’s name follows the alphabetic tradition of Bs and Ds. It’s called “the Outbound F.”
To contact the reporter on this story: Jesse Drucker in New York at jdrucker4@bloomberg.net.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Gary Putka at gputka@bloomberg.net.
Sweden Shows Central Bankers How to Fight Next Asset Bubble
Sweden’s central bank may set the direction for other policy makers as it looks beyond conventional inflation targets to asset-price growth in an effort to prevent the next bubble.
“Not countering asset-price increases has been the conventional wisdom among central banks, but what has it actually resulted in?” said Tina Mortensen, an economist at Citigroup Inc. in London. “Surely the current crisis has made central bankers rethink policy; Sweden is actually facing this problem” because “asset prices and monetary policy are a hot topic,” she said.
Riksbank Governor Stefan Ingves has raised the repo rate four times since July even as inflation remains below the bank’s 2 percent target. The increases occurred as house prices move above pre-crisis levels and credit growth hovers near 9 percent. While Sweden raises rates, the U.S., the euro region, Japan and the U.K. are keeping borrowing costs at record lows.
The financial crisis that started more than two years ago was exacerbated by central banks holding rates too low as inflation gauges failed to capture asset-price growth, according to Johnny Akerholm, president of the Helsinki-based Nordic Investment Bank. He says most policy makers are repeating the mistake.
“We are practically re-running the same situation these days,” he said in his bank’s Dec. 17 newsletter. “Rates are low and the central banks are ‘printing money’ while virtually all prices, except the consumer prices in industrial countries, are increasing rapidly.”
Rates ‘Normalized’
Policy makers in Europe and the U.S. have started to warn of the risks associated with low rates. Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee member Andrew Sentance voted for a seventh month to raise the benchmark from a record-low 0.5 percent at the bank’s Dec. 9 meeting. Paul Fisher, the bank’s markets director, told the Daily Telegraph last week that rates should be “normalized” to about 5 percent.
European Central Bank Executive Board member Juergen Stark says monetary policy should address the threat of financial imbalances and wants forecasting models to provide broader gauges of the economy. He’s spent the past year warning that an extension of the ECB’s liquidity program risks sowing “the seeds for new imbalances.”
Still, ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet said as recently as Dec. 2 the bank will keep providing emergency funds to banks through the first quarter. The ECB’s benchmark rate has remained at a record low 1 percent since May 2009.
Mopping Up Bubbles
In the U.S., Kansas City Fed President Thomas Hoenig said this month the “continued high level of monetary accommodation” may “destabilize the economy.” The Fed has kept its main rate at zero to 0.25 percent since December 2008. The Fed said last month it will buy $600 billion of Treasuries through June, helping keep yields low.
“There’s a risk that if policy makers react to a bubble bursting by aggressively loosening monetary policy, it may lead to new damaging bubbles emerging,” said Ben May, an economist at Capital Economics Ltd. in London. “The conventional wisdom amongst policy makers has been that you shouldn’t lean on bubbles and that the best thing to do is just to try to mop them up when they burst. In hindsight, that looks like a mistake.”
Swedish headline inflation has lagged behind the Riksbank’s target since December 2008. Inflation adjusted for mortgage costs will remain below target through 2013, the bank estimates.
Growth vs Debt
House prices, by contrast, rose for a 19th consecutive month in the quarter through November, gaining at an annual rate of 5 percent. The Riksbank, which raised its repo rate to 1.25 percent on Dec. 15, said then higher rates are needed to slow credit growth.
The bank is also trying to steer the fastest economic rebound in the European Union as it estimates growth of 5.5 percent this year. It expects the repo rate to average 3.3 percent in 2013, while economic growth will slow to 2.3 percent in 2012.
“The focus on issues such as the level of household debt suggests the Riksbank might rather have a period of slightly weaker growth or below-target inflation than a surge in indebtedness and perhaps another boom in house prices,” May said.
Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke said in a Nov. 16 speech that policy makers “have to keep an open mind” on the possibility of using interest rates to pop asset bubbles. He added that the “best approach here, if at all possible, is to use supervisory and regulatory methods.”
Bypassing Rules
Outside Europe and the U.S., Bank of Israel Governor Stanley Fischer has incorporated bubble fighting into policy in a country where housing supply is shaped by government control of land. Fischer, who also oversees Israel’s banking regulation, left the benchmark rate at 2 percent this week in part because house prices cooled.
According to Mortensen at Citigroup, regulation alone has done little to cool Sweden’s house-price growth. Banks, which have had to cap mortgage lending at 85 percent of a property’s value since Oct. 1, “just seem to come up with alternative products” to bypass the rule, Mortensen said.
“I wouldn’t be surprised, given what we have just been through, if this leads to some kind of rethinking, also globally,” she said.
To contact the reporter on this story: Kati Pohjanpalo in Helsinki at kpohjanpalo@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Tasneem Brogger at tbrogger@bloomberg.net
“Not countering asset-price increases has been the conventional wisdom among central banks, but what has it actually resulted in?” said Tina Mortensen, an economist at Citigroup Inc. in London. “Surely the current crisis has made central bankers rethink policy; Sweden is actually facing this problem” because “asset prices and monetary policy are a hot topic,” she said.
Riksbank Governor Stefan Ingves has raised the repo rate four times since July even as inflation remains below the bank’s 2 percent target. The increases occurred as house prices move above pre-crisis levels and credit growth hovers near 9 percent. While Sweden raises rates, the U.S., the euro region, Japan and the U.K. are keeping borrowing costs at record lows.
The financial crisis that started more than two years ago was exacerbated by central banks holding rates too low as inflation gauges failed to capture asset-price growth, according to Johnny Akerholm, president of the Helsinki-based Nordic Investment Bank. He says most policy makers are repeating the mistake.
“We are practically re-running the same situation these days,” he said in his bank’s Dec. 17 newsletter. “Rates are low and the central banks are ‘printing money’ while virtually all prices, except the consumer prices in industrial countries, are increasing rapidly.”
Rates ‘Normalized’
Policy makers in Europe and the U.S. have started to warn of the risks associated with low rates. Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee member Andrew Sentance voted for a seventh month to raise the benchmark from a record-low 0.5 percent at the bank’s Dec. 9 meeting. Paul Fisher, the bank’s markets director, told the Daily Telegraph last week that rates should be “normalized” to about 5 percent.
European Central Bank Executive Board member Juergen Stark says monetary policy should address the threat of financial imbalances and wants forecasting models to provide broader gauges of the economy. He’s spent the past year warning that an extension of the ECB’s liquidity program risks sowing “the seeds for new imbalances.”
Still, ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet said as recently as Dec. 2 the bank will keep providing emergency funds to banks through the first quarter. The ECB’s benchmark rate has remained at a record low 1 percent since May 2009.
Mopping Up Bubbles
In the U.S., Kansas City Fed President Thomas Hoenig said this month the “continued high level of monetary accommodation” may “destabilize the economy.” The Fed has kept its main rate at zero to 0.25 percent since December 2008. The Fed said last month it will buy $600 billion of Treasuries through June, helping keep yields low.
“There’s a risk that if policy makers react to a bubble bursting by aggressively loosening monetary policy, it may lead to new damaging bubbles emerging,” said Ben May, an economist at Capital Economics Ltd. in London. “The conventional wisdom amongst policy makers has been that you shouldn’t lean on bubbles and that the best thing to do is just to try to mop them up when they burst. In hindsight, that looks like a mistake.”
Swedish headline inflation has lagged behind the Riksbank’s target since December 2008. Inflation adjusted for mortgage costs will remain below target through 2013, the bank estimates.
Growth vs Debt
House prices, by contrast, rose for a 19th consecutive month in the quarter through November, gaining at an annual rate of 5 percent. The Riksbank, which raised its repo rate to 1.25 percent on Dec. 15, said then higher rates are needed to slow credit growth.
The bank is also trying to steer the fastest economic rebound in the European Union as it estimates growth of 5.5 percent this year. It expects the repo rate to average 3.3 percent in 2013, while economic growth will slow to 2.3 percent in 2012.
“The focus on issues such as the level of household debt suggests the Riksbank might rather have a period of slightly weaker growth or below-target inflation than a surge in indebtedness and perhaps another boom in house prices,” May said.
Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke said in a Nov. 16 speech that policy makers “have to keep an open mind” on the possibility of using interest rates to pop asset bubbles. He added that the “best approach here, if at all possible, is to use supervisory and regulatory methods.”
Bypassing Rules
Outside Europe and the U.S., Bank of Israel Governor Stanley Fischer has incorporated bubble fighting into policy in a country where housing supply is shaped by government control of land. Fischer, who also oversees Israel’s banking regulation, left the benchmark rate at 2 percent this week in part because house prices cooled.
According to Mortensen at Citigroup, regulation alone has done little to cool Sweden’s house-price growth. Banks, which have had to cap mortgage lending at 85 percent of a property’s value since Oct. 1, “just seem to come up with alternative products” to bypass the rule, Mortensen said.
“I wouldn’t be surprised, given what we have just been through, if this leads to some kind of rethinking, also globally,” she said.
To contact the reporter on this story: Kati Pohjanpalo in Helsinki at kpohjanpalo@bloomberg.net
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Tasneem Brogger at tbrogger@bloomberg.net
피드 구독하기:
글 (Atom)